Dungeon Settlers promises a combination that should be an easy sell: colony builder plus dungeon crawler.
After a full seven-hour stream, however, it currently feels much more like the latter.
The settlement side was surprisingly basic in the scenario played. With the colony safely isolated on an island like landmass, there was little concern about defending or securing it. The only reason to develop it at all was the requirement of work benches to be inside. Dungeon expeditions provide resources needed for survival, construction, and research, making them the real engine driving the game forward.
Thankfully, that part works. Combat is interesting, the systems generally make sense once learned, and the entire experience feels smooth and well constructed for the beginning of Early Access.
The problem is that it all just felt… fine.
There was very little actually wrong with Dungeon Settlers, but after seven hours there was equally little pulling me toward another seven. Hopefully Early Access adds more content, depth, and excitement to an already solid foundation.
Dungeon Settlers is therefore placed into Cryostasis.
The dungeon can wait.
The settlers need more to settle.
Pronouncement: Placed into cryostasis.